FYI, I'm doing a YouTube debate this evening at 5:30 PST with Matt Slick on the topic of "Atheism, Christianity, and morality". It will also be recorded so you don't have to watch it live. Here is the link.
Wednesday, January 13, 2021
Sunday, January 10, 2021
Arnold Schwarzenegger just released a video in which he compares the Jan 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol to Kristallnacht, and draws a straight line from the Proud Boys to the early Nazis by way of his own personal experience growing up in Austria in the long shadow of World War II. The video gets a little corny and treacly towards the end, but the analogy is apt and the warning is one we would all do well to heed. Worth watching at least the first half of the video.
A dry run of the attack on the U.S. capitol occurred the day before in northern California:
Here in California’s rural, conservative northern counties — where people have long wanted to split from California and form a new state called Jefferson — the kind of anger and distrust of the government that Trump has fomented is on full display.
And it is not likely to go away any time soon, because some residents believe there is great political utility in making government officials believe that potential violence could become all too real.
“We have to make politicians scared again,” Carlos Zapata, who attended the supervisors’ meeting, told The Times. “If politicians do not fear the people they govern, that relationship is broken.”
The last four years, and even Jan 6, have been a warmup. The main event, the real damage that Donald Trump will do to our country, is yet to come.
Speaking of prophetic observations, here is a particularly profound one made by Hans Howe back in 2017:
Trump administration lies constantly but doesn’t even attempt to make it seem like they aren’t lying.
Trump’s supporters don’t care about being lied to. You can point out the lies until you’re blue in the face, but it makes no difference to them. Why? Because it is just a game to them. The media lies, bloggers lie, politicians lie, it’s just all a bunch of lies. Facts don’t matter because those are lies also. Those trolls on Twitter, 4Chan, T_D, etc. are just having a good laugh. They are congratulating each other for being so smart. We are fools for still believing in anything.
Well worth reading the whole thing.
I don't think I'm going very far out on a limb to make this prediction, but I just wanted to get it on the record before it happened. It seems like some low-lying prophetic fruit that I just felt like picking this morning. (Oh, and I also predict that he will also issue blanket pardons to himself and his family.)
As long as I'm writing, an administrative note: I am now moderating all comments on this blog. For seventeen years I have not done this because I believed in free speech, and I still do. But my recent posts have attracted conspiracy cockroaches. I would just ban the worst offenders, but unfortunately the Blogger platform doesn't allow that, so I'll have to filter everything manually. I deeply regret having to take this step, but I will no longer allow my blog to be an outlet for repeated blatant lies that are a clear and present danger to the country that has been my home for most of my life.
So here's the new rule: I will no longer publish anonymous or pseudonymous defenses of right-wing propaganda. If you want to defend these positions here, you're going to have to do it under your real identity, as I have been doing for the last 17 years. If you really have the courage of your convictions then show your face. If not, then go crawl back into the holes from whence you came like the cowards that you are.
[UPDATE] One pseudonymous coward has taken to the comment box to whine about censorship. Tough. One man's censorship is another man's exercise of editorial control. I have actually had an editorial policy since the beginning, but it hasn't really been necessary to enforce it much until now. If you send a letter to the editor of the New York Times they are under no obligation to publish it, and neither am I. You are perfectly free to write your own blog if you want to be heard. But this blog belongs to me, and if you're not willing to show your face or demonstrate that you have a basic grip on reality you are not welcome here. Begone, pseudonymous trolls.
Friday, January 08, 2021
Article III section 3 of the Constitution of the United States says:
"Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort."
Donald Trump, while wielding the authority of the Presidency, incited a violent insurrection against the government of the United States. It cannot possibly be any clearer that he committed treason, and hence he is an Enemy of the United States, and hence anyone who still actively supports him at this point is giving aid and comfort to an Enemy of the United States and hence also guilty of treason under the Constitution. I make these allegations fully cognizant of the fact that treason is a capital crime in the U.S.
Of course, very few people will take this seriously despite the fact that it is manifestly true. Donald Trump will not be indicted for treason, let alone convicted and executed for it, despite the fact that if anyone else had done what he did they would already be in shackles. And if that person had been black, they would probably be dead already.
Seriously, imagine if Barack Obama had done the exact same thing as Donald Trump after the 2016 election: made baseless accusations of voter fraud and claims that the election was stolen from Hillary, and incited a mob of angry black men to storm the capital. How do you think Republicans would have reacted to that?
The sad fact of the matter is that 70 million Americans voted for Donald Trump, and while some of them might have had a change of heart after the events of Jan 6, most surely have not. Not even the actual manifestation of an attempt at violent overthrow of the government will dissuade these people that Donald Trump is the Chosen One, and anyone who dares accuse him of treason, indeed who dares to question him in any way, will face their wrath at the ballot box and now, quite possibly, in the streets or in their homes. And so there will be much wailing and gnashing of teeth and wringing of hands. There might even be ignominy of a second impeachment and removal from office (though I'll give you long odds against). But there will not be justice. Donald Trump may live out his remaining days in disgrace, but not in prison.
I think it's really important, though, to be clear about what brought us to this pass, because it is plain as day: we are here because Donald Trump lied. And he lied and he lied and he lied and he lied and he lied and then he lied some more. And eventually people started to think that there just had to be some truth to the lies, not because there was any actual evidence that they were true, but simply because no one could possibly lie that much, right? Where there is smoke there has to be fire. So the election was stolen, not because there was any evidence for it, but simply because Donald Trump said so. And said it again. And again. And again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again...
And it worked. And it continues to work. And that is our ultimate shame: we have built a society where lying works as long as your lie is big enough and you repeat is often enough and you never back down, not even in the face of manifest catastrophe. In this regard we are extremely fortunate that Donald Trump is merely a consummately skilled con man and not a scheming despotic mastermind, because if he were the latter we'd staring down the barrel of a much bigger gun.
How did we get here? How did we build a society full of people so utterly incapable of skepticism and critical thought that it gave us not only Donald Trump and his followers in the tens of millions, but anti-vaxers and anti-maskers and holocaust denialists and lunar landing denialists and climate-change denialists and flat earthers and birthers and 9-11 truthers people proudly waving the Confederate flag saying it has nothing to do with slavery?
I submit that it is because, in American society, denial of the truth is considered a virtue. Except that it's not called denial of the truth, it's called "being a person of faith."
Now, I want to be very clear here that I am NOT signing on to Richard Dawkins's rabid anti-religion agenda. I'm sure many religious folks are fine people. Some of my best friends are religious. The irony here is intended to be dark humor, but in all seriousness, I am about to levy some pretty harsh criticism on religion, and I want to be very clear that there is a distinction between that and religious people. The problem with "people of faith" is the "faith" part, not necessarily the "people" part.
The problem with faith is not that it leads you to believe in things that aren't true (though it certainly can do that). The problem is that it leads you to believe in things without evidence, or worse, in direct contradiction to the evidence. Again, I want to be clear that this is not necessarily bad. There are circumstances where believing in things without evidence or contrary to evidence can be very beneficial, which is probably why we evolved the tendency in the first place. If you believe you can kill that sabre tooth tiger despite all the evidence that it is hopeless, that might spur you to attempt to kill it, and you just might surprise yourself and succeed where your more rational competitor might have just given up and cowered in a corner and gotten eaten as a result. In some circumstances, suspension of disbelief really can be a virtue.
But it can also be incredibly dangerous. It's not mere happenstance that a large majority of evangelical Christians support Trump, nor that many of the insurgents were waving signs that said, "Jesus saves." They have been trained to bow to authority, to submit themselves to the Will of God, many from a very young age. I'm sure many of them believed in their heart of hearts that they were doing the will of God. I'm sure many of them still believe it.
People of faith now need to wrestle with this if they want democracy to survive in the U.S. Faith can lead to hope where there might otherwise be despair, action where there might otherwise be complacency, courage where there might otherwise be fear. But it can also lead to people doing stupid shit like what we saw two days ago.
Where faith becomes especially dangerous is when it leaves the realm of the ambiguous and the spiritual and places itself squarely at odds with objective reality. Your faith in your ability to vanquish the sabre tooth tiger will be put to the test when you try to act on it. Either you will vanquish the tiger or it will vanquish you. That kind of dynamic prevents faith from spinning too wildly out of control. If you see enough of your tribe mates being eaten by sabre tooth tigers you may start to rethink the wisdom of believing in your prowess against them. But your faith in (say) being rewarded in the afterlife cannot be put to the test until it is too late for anyone to act on it if you turn out to be wrong. And if your faith is too strong you may well end up believing that, say, Donald Trump is telling the truth when he says he won the election because it was God's will so it cannot possibly be any other way. If the evidence says otherwise, well, then the evidence must be wrong. Too much faith leads inevitably down the conspiracy rabbit hole.
The events of Jan 6 were horrific, but we actually dodged a bullet because it could have been so much worse. Think of what might have happened if the rioters had been organized and brought their assault rifles. Or if, instead of inciting this riot, Donald Trump had instead decided that the best way to for him to stir the pot would be to nuke Tehran. (And if you think he wouldn't go that far then you really haven't been paying attention.)
Faith can be a virtue, but it is not an unalloyed good. I'm not a person of faith so there's not much I can do to help solve this problem other than to point it out. If you consider yourself to be a person of faith, this ball is squarely in your court.
Thursday, January 07, 2021
It was never a question of whether Donald Trump would destroy the Republican party, but when and how, and whether he would take the rest of the country (and possibly the world) down along with it. The one silver lining to yesterday's horrific events in our nation's capitol is that we finally have the beginning of a real answer. Mike Pence and Mitch McConnell finally joined the rest of the rats fleeing the rapidly sinking S.S. Trump, leaving Ted Cruz at the helm. I predict he will stay there like a hyena on a rotting corpse because he is so hungry for power that no matter how bad things get he will not be able to tear himself away from all those tasty, tasty MAGA voters.
That Trump's reign would end something like this was utterly predictable from the start. I'm sorry, but if you didn't see something like this coming, you really haven't been paying attention for the last four years. Donald Trump was never going to stop abusing his power until he got smacked down hard. In fact, he still hasn't gotten smacked down hard, and so he is still not going to stop. Maybe he will get smacked down in the next two weeks (by a largely symbolic second impeachment), or the next two years (by being prosecuted for his various crimes), but until that actually happens (and it is far from clear that it will) Trump is not going to stop being himself even now.
But the Republican party, thank God, is done for. Donald Trump has set out a very stark choice for Republicans: follow me, or follow the law. As with everything Trump does, there is no room for compromise or nuance. You are either with him or you are against him. Choose.
As bad as yesterday was, we still have a lot to be grateful for because it could have been oh so much worse. Imagine if the mob that descended yesterday had been disciplined and well-organized and armed with assault rifles instead of the ragtag motley crew that it turned out to be. Or imagine if, instead of a riot in Washington, Trump had decided that it would be a good idea to nuke Tehran on his way out the door. Yesterday could very well have been the Reichstag fire. Instead it was the beer hall putsch.
But make no mistake, this war is far from over. Yes, the Republican party is finished, at least for now. It will split into the Trump wing and the anti-Trump wing, and that will blunt its influence for a while until it can heal and reorganize. But we have much to fear from what will inevitably rise from those ashes. The 70 million people who voted for Trump in November of 2020 are still out there. They are still nursing their grievances and concocting their conspiracy theories and, most frightening of all, waiting for someone new to lead them to the promised land where white people will once again assume their rightful place at the pinnacle of society. Ted Cruz is even now maneuvering to fill that role. Cruz is even less principled and more power hungry than Trump, and, what should really scare the living daylights out of you, a hell of a lot smarter.
In the end, the only thing that saved us from total disaster this time around was Donald Trump's incompetence. Not Mitch McConnell, not Mike Pence, not Bill Barr, not Ron Cohen, not Robert Mueller, not Chuck Schumer, not Nancy Pelosi. If Trump had been just a little bit less stupid, if he'd actually thought things through, if he had any skills at all beyond bloviating in front of a crowd, we might well have learned the hard way that our democracy is a whole lot more fragile than most people think it is even now.
So yes, breathe a small sigh of relief that the bulwark of democracy appears to have held this time around. But don't take too much comfort in this because the next time we might not be so lucky. And there will be a next time. What happened yesterday was just the latest skirmish in a conflict that has been running cold and hot since before the founding of the Republic. Democracy has won this battle, but the war is far from over.