As long as I'm ranting about Republican hypocrisy, I feel I should say a word about the secretive and thoroughly undemocratic process being employed by them to pass the Trumpcare bill. If history is any guide, this will come back to bite them badly. But Republicans don't seem to learn from history. (Neither do Democrats, actually, but they aren't the ones trying to take my health insurance away.)
I was at a fundraiser recently where a highly placed government official (ahem) was discussing why Hillary lost the election. A major contributing factor, he (because most highly placed government officials are still men) said was her wiffly-waffly opposition to the Trans Pacific Partnership. This highly placed government official (OK, I'm going to start calling him Fred even though that's not his real name) said that the TPP was widely (and correctly IMHO) perceived among working-class Americans as a threat to their livelihoods, and that if she didn't come out with a full-throated repudiation of it she would lose their votes. More prescient words have rarely been spoken in politics.
But this left Hillary in a jam because the TPP was Barack Obama's baby, so Obama told Hillary that if she opposed the TPP that she would lose his support. Obama believed (and probably still believes) that the TPP was necessary in order to prevent China from basically taking over the world. And he was right about that. The problem with the TPP was not that it wasn't needed -- it was (and still is). The problem with the TPP was the process by which it was negotiated.
In the management of human affairs, the process by which a conclusion is reached is as important -- sometimes more important -- than the conclusion itself. People want to feel empowered even if (perhaps especially if) they are not. That is the reason democracy works, not because it produces the best outcomes, but because it's the best way humans have come up with to get people to accept outcomes they don't like without resorting to violence.
The TPP failed in no small measure because it was negotiated in secret. A bunch of American corporate leaders got together and negotiated a deal which, unsurprisingly, would have been very good for American corporations, under the tacit assumption that what's good for American corporations is good for the American people. And maybe that's even true, but to argue over that is to badly miss the point which is that the secrecy surrounding the proceedings made ordinary people feel as if they did not have a seat at the table.
Now Mitch McConnell is making the exact same mistake with the TrumpCare bill, and for the exact same reason. He knows that the bill will never survive the light of day, because the goal of the bill is not to improve health care, but to give tax breaks to the wealthy. But people are starting to get wise to the trickle-down scam, so he can't actually admit that.
I don't know if the Senate will manage to get a bill passed in the next two weeks or not. If they do, I don't know whether the House will manage to pass it, or if the Senate version will be insufficiently cruel to placate the House Freedom Caucus. If all this manages to happen, I don't even know for sure if Trump will sign it because he's so mercurial that trying to predict anything he does is a fool's errand.
But I do know this: if the Republicans do manage to repeal Obamacare, that will be the end of them, not because the product will be bad (though it almost certainly will be) but because it was done in secret. Americans don't like their government to operate in secrecy. The secret negotiation of the TPP ultimately cost Hillary Clinton the presidency, and I predict it will cost the Republicans control of Congress in 2018.
At least I hope so. Because if we let the Republicans get away with this, we're fucked.
Sunday, June 18, 2017
New Gingrich! For saying that "the president “technically” can’t even obstruct justice" after leading the charge to impeach Bill Clinton for obstructing justice. Congratulations, Mr. Gingrich! Being the most hypocritical Republican is quite an achievement in this day and age.